Chocolate is VERY RARE! One of the original 9. “Old face”, retired in 1998, BD 1993, PVC pellets Swing tag: 4th generation Tush Tag: 3rd generation, no stamp, misspelled surface “sufrace” NO STAR. The item “Chocolate Beanie Baby (RARE, retired)” is in sale since Saturday, July 11, 2015. This item is in the category “Toys & Hobbies\Beanbag Plush\Ty\Beanie Babies-Original\Retired”. The seller is “meghan0410″ and is located in Fowlerville, Michigan. This item can be shipped to United States.